In Sweden and in other parts of Europe there are concerns that seals and birds compete with humans for fish resources. For the Baltic Sea, an international study now shows that this competition is a reality.
"Because fish is nutrient-rich food and angling provides valuable recreation, the increased populations of seals and fish-eating birds in the Baltic have resulted in a sometimes contentious debate over the effects of these animals on the fish stocks. The debates are often based on assumptions, which is why I took the initiative to look at the problem from a scientific viewpoint," said Sture Hansson, Professor of Ecology, Environment and Plant Sciences at Stockholm University.
Together with 4 researchers from the Department of Aquatic Resources at the Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences (SLU) and 7 other colleagues from countries around the Baltic, Hansson has estimated birds' and seals' fish consumption. Seals are the primary fish-eating mammals, and their consumption is about the same as that of all birds together. Humans catch 3 to 4 times more fish than seals and birds combined.
Small-scale coastal fishing most impacted by wildlife
The fishing grounds most impacted by competition from wildlife are the coastal areas with species like perch, pike, pikeperch, brown trout, salmon, whitefish and vendace. Seals and cormorants consume similar amounts as humans. Because we know that these fish are impacted by human fishing activities, it's reasonable to conclude that they are also impacted by predation from seals and birds. Wildlife thus competes with humans for these fish resources.
For some unknown reason, there has been such a dramatic reduction in eel that they are now considered critically endangered. Eel fishing has been drastically reduced and complete bans are being discussed. In this case as well, it is worth noting that the eel consumption by cormorants is at the same level as human fishing.
Based on these results, the scientists conclude that the impacts of seals and birds (primarily cormorants) on fish stocks should be considered in future management plans. Both reductions in fishing quotas and wildlife predation rates should be considered when fish stocks decrease so precipitously. This might take the shape of hunting or harassments to reduce animal abundances.
Seals and birds had no major impact on open sea fisheries for herring, sprat and cod.
The article Competition for the fish – fish extraction from the Baltic Sea by humans, aquatic mammals, and birds, is published in ICES Journal of Marine Science
Sture Hansson, Stockholm Univ., +46708-140599, Sture.Hansson@su.se
Ulf Bergström, Department of Aquatic Resources, SLU, +4610-478 4117, Ulf.Bergström@slu.se
Fishery catch: 700,000 tons/yr, of which 650,000 tons are herring, sprat and cod
Consumption by seals: 100,000 tons/yr, of which 60,000 tons are herring, sprat and cod. Grey seal 75,000 tons, ringed seal 20,000 tons and harbour seals 5,000 tons
Consumption by birds: 100,000 tons/yr, of which 30,000 tons are herring, sprat and cod. Cormorants consume 40,000 tons/yr, while razorbill, common guillemot, common and red-breasted merganser each consume about 10,000 tons/yr. The remaining 20,000 tons are consumed by other bird species.